TISG: Court partially revokes protective measures, five owners regain the right to terminate contracts
The negotiated crisis settlement procedure involving The Italian Sea Group is entering a new critical phase. The Florence Court has ordered the partial revocation of the protective measures confirmed on April 20, 2026, accepting the complaints filed by five yacht owners. While limited in its immediate effects, the decision introduces a legal distinction likely to carry significant weight — and potentially set a precedent — throughout the custom yacht industry. The Court ruled that the yachts already owned by the claimant owners cannot be considered either assets of the entrepreneur or assets instrumental to the operation of the business. As such, they fall outside the scope of protection provided by the negotiated settlement procedure. At the same time, the five owners cannot be treated as creditors subject to the protective measures, since their contractual right to performance cannot be satisfied through enforcement or precautionary actions involving the yachts themselves.
The practical consequence is straightforward: the five claimants regain full authority to exercise the rights provided under their respective contracts, including the possible termination of those agreements. The protective measures, however, remain fully effective with respect to all other yacht owners and creditors of the group, and the overall restructuring procedure continues uninterrupted.
The Italian Sea Group attempted to downplay the immediate impact of the ruling, stating in its release that “as far as the yacht-owning companies are concerned, in substance nothing changes in the contractual relationship.” The message was clearly aimed at reassuring commercial partners and signaling the group’s intention to avoid immediate operational repercussions on yachts currently under construction. Discussions with stakeholders, suppliers, financial institutions and yacht owners are continuing within the framework of the economic and financial rebalancing plan already underway.
From a negotiation standpoint, however, the situation has objectively become more complex. The partial revocation strengthens the position of the five owners involved, who will now enter future negotiations with significantly greater contractual leverage. The overall balance of the restructuring process could therefore be affected.
Yet the broader significance of the ruling lies in the precedent it may establish. The Court’s decision outlines a clear distinction between protecting a company in financial distress and protecting the property rights of yacht owners — a far from theoretical issue in a sector where vessels under construction may contractually belong to the client already during advanced stages of the build process. Shipyards, investors and high-end suppliers involved in large yacht projects will all have strong reasons to examine this ruling carefully.
The Italian Sea Group confirmed that it will continue to update the market regarding developments in the procedure, in compliance with applicable regulations.
©PressMare - All rights reserved
